|
Video
& Audio Cassettes Vcd's
and Dvd's

|
| |
The Heresies of
Sayyid Qutb in Light of the
Statements of the Ulamaa (Part 3)
Source:
Baraa'ah Ulamaa il-Ummah Min Tazkiyah Ahl il-Bid'ah (by Isaam bin
Abdullah as-Sinaanee) SalafiPublications.Com
All Praise is due to Allaah who made it sufficient honour for
His servants to defend the honour and integrity of the Prophets of Allaah and
His Messengers and their Companions. And all praise is due to Allaah who made it
sufficient disgrace and ignominy for the biased partisans that they defend and
aggrandize the Mockers of the Messengers and the Slanderers of Caliphs and
Companions, declaring some of them to be disbelievers, others to be pathetic and
senile, and yet others guilty of deception and treachery - let alone their
defence of the writings of falsehood which contain but the innovations of the Jahmiyyah,
Mu'tazilah, Ash'ariyyah,
Khawarij, the despicable Rafidah and others
- displaying the extremism of their Irjaa' in all of that - and then affirming
the affair by calling such a one to be "Shaheed" without making the
exception (Istithnaa).
We present to you the some samples of the handwritten notes of both
Shaikh Ibn Uthaimeen and Shaikh
Salih al-Fawzaan on the book, "Baraa'ah Ulamaa il-Ummah Min
Tazkiyaat Ahl ul-Bid'ah wal-Mudhammah" as well as Shaikh
al-Albani's commendation and praise of
Shaikh Rabee's
efforts in exposing
the deviation and ignorance of Sayyid
Qutb.
This book is a specific refutation of those who use the intercession of
Shaikh Ibn Baaz for Sayyid Qutb prior to his death as a justification for the
defence of his heretical beliefs and writings.
IMPORTANT NOTE: We see that if a
Qutubi reads this he
will soon interject and claim: Why do you not also take the words of
Shaikh Salih al-Fawzaan or the Committee in criticism of those besides Sayyid
Qutb? - then we say because all of the Ulamaa have refuted Qutb, from Imaam
al-Albani,
Imaam Ibn Baz, Shaikh Abdul-Muhsin al-Abbaad, Shaikh Salih
al-Fawzaan, Shaikh
Mahmood Shakir (as far back as 1952, when he refuted Qutb four times publicly,
for his scathing attacks on the Companions - despite that he still oversaw the
printing of his book of Rafd, al-Adaalah al-Ijtimaa'iyyah up until his death,
and it continues to be published by his brother Mohamamd Qutb to this day, the
while it is not free from revilement of some of the Companions),
Shaikh Ubayd
al-Jaabiree, Shaikh al-Lahaydaan, Shaikh Hammad
al-Ansaree,
Shaikh
Rabee' Bin
Haadee, Shaikh Abdullah
ad-Dawaish, Shaikh Salih
as-Suhaymee, Shaikh Abdul-Azeez Aal-Shaikh, let alone scores of others, both from
Ahl us-Sunnah
wal-Jamaa'ah,
and from outside of it, such as the Innovators of Ikhwaan such as Qaradawi and
the likes. There has always been a unanimous concensus on the heresy, deviation
and Kharijism of Sayyid Qutb - denied only by those engrossed and infatuated
with Qutubism and its ideals - but in all that while never did you show
sincerity of purpose
Oh Qutubi, and accept them and their verdicts! Rather, you
bemused yourself because the proponents of Qutubism of our times labelled the
above scholars as being "the scholars of womens menses and
impurities", "ignorant of fiqh ul-waqi'", "the scholars of
the desert" and what is worse than all of that.
But despite all of that you found fault with those who merely narrated their
verdicts and who brought these verdicts to the attention of the people -
advising them for the sake of Allaah - to flee from this man and his teachings,
and then you reviled them and cursed them, showing anger and hatred for the sake
of your sayyid, Sayyid Qutb - but you did not show hatred and anger for Moosa (alaihi-salaam)
and nor for Uthmaan
(radiyallaahu anhu) and nor for Bani Umayyah, and nor for
the sake of the Islamic Sharee'ah when your sayyid called for parts of it to be
abolished, because it is not suitable and relevant for the times - showing the
extremism of your Irjaa' in all of that. So do not preach to us, O Qutubi about
the verdicts of the Scholars, when you are the one's who have been most in
need of such a preaching, with respect to your sayyid and his heretical
beliefs and teachings, ever since 1952, when Shaikh Mahmood Shakir exposed his
poisonous Rafd and exposed his heretical beliefs.
So we say, exposing the great fraud and deception of
Qutubism:
ONE: Shaikh
al-Albani's Written Communication to
Shaikh
Rabee'
This was written after the Shaikh completed a reading of 'al-Awaasim
Minal-Qawaasim' shortly before his death. And this is also an uncovering of that
Qutubi who used some very old words of Shaikh al-Albani to defend Sayyid Qutb
and his heretical writings. It is abundantly clear that at that particular time
Shaikh al-Albani had not made a thorough study of all the works of Qutb and
hence did not speak in criticism of him. However, when the affair became clear
to him at the hands of Shaikh Rabee' then he wrote the communication below. A
translation of it can be found in Part 1 of this series.
TWO: Shaikh Salih
al-Fawzaan's Adjustments to the Title
The Shaikh making some adjustments to the naming of the series and also
changing the title of the book by adding the word "Wal-Mudhammah" to
the end of the title.
THREE: The Letter Sent by the Compiler of the Book to the Defender of
Sayyid Qutb
This is the letter sent by the compiler of this particular book (Isaam
bin Abdullaah as-Sinaani) to a Qutubi who had attempted to defend Sayyid Qutb by
the intercession of
Imaam Ibn Baaz. Shaikh Fawzaan makes some additional notes
to it. The text of the letter mentions that Qutb had very great and serious
errors and that this type of reasoning only deceives the youth, who will be led
astray by his heresies. Shaikh Fawzaan adds "Then, the Shaikh (i.e. Bin Baz)
did that (i.e. interceded for Qutb) before it became clear from Sayyid Qutb
what was clear in his books", and some other brief notes further down.
 |
FOUR: Shaikh Salih
al-Fawzaan Adjusting His Own Words
Here Shaikh Fawzaan makes a few adjustments to his own words in
refutation of Adnaan Ar'oor
(who is now pushing his own form of insidious
Qutubism). Shaikh Fawzaan describes Qutb as a Jaahil, ignoramus, with no
knowledge, and of course this is indeed true in the case of Sayyid Qutb. The
translation of this is found in Part 1 of this series.
 |
FIVE: Shaikh Ibn Uthaimeen Advising A Change Related to the
Ordering of Content
Shaikh Ibn Uthaimeen asking for the section titled "The Salafi
Manhaj" to be put first, before "The Qutubi Manhaj". And it is
here that we confirm, once again, that Qutubism and the Qutubi Methodology is a
real and tangible reality and exists - even though the well-known Qutubists of
the West such as Ali Timimi and Idris Palmer have been trying to deny their own
existence for numerous years. Closet-Qutubism is now officially dead.
The title of the page reads "Two Ways That Do Not Meet, Separated By the
East and the West", and the first three quotations are from Sayyid Qutb's 'Zilaal'
in which he performs takfir of the whole of mankind and every Muslim society and
also in which he says that what Islam requires is revolutions (inqilaab) in
every place and location in order to forcefully impose the Sharee'ah - and that
this is the highest and most lofty goal (Zilaal 3/1451) and inshaa'allaah we
will translate this for all to see that this man and his writings are but the
legacy of Dhul-Khuwaisarah at-Tameemi - and from Allaah is the refuge.
Note, Shaikh Ibn Uthaimeen praised the book, after reading it.
 |
Closing Remarks
It is important that the Qutubis address the issue of following the
verdicts of the Salafi Ulamaa - concerning which they have had clear problems
with over the last 8 years - before they begin to display love and
affection for the same scholars who - in their view - used to be the "the
scholars of women's menses and impurities". When they have come to terms
with this, then inshaa'allaah we can open up a discussion concerning Imaam,
Takfir, Irjaa and the position of Imaam al-Albani and Imaam Ibn Baaz - both of
whom the Qutubis accuse of being Murji'ah, and having the Irjaa' of Jahm
Ibn Safwaan - due to their position on ruling by other than what Allaah has
revealed.
| |
|